T'eyla Minh (teylaminh) wrote,
T'eyla Minh
teylaminh

  • Mood:

Fandom for February: Day Two

Right then, here we go. Prepare to scrub your eyeballs.

Day 02 - Your Least Favourite Ship

Actually, now I come to think about it, that question seems to be an oxymoron. You have ships because you like them, not because you don't. In any case, this is a pairing I absolutely hated from the moment the rumour mill started turning right up until it had been and gone. Several years later and I still haven't forgiven whichever idiot thought this up.

Chakotay and Seven of Nine from Star Trek: Voyager

It takes a really special talent to produce a pairing which destroys two entirely separate, better and more popular pairings in one fell swoop. And those two destroyed pairings were in fact my preferred two out of this particular fandom.

The trouble started when Jeri Taylor, one of the show's creators, left the writing pool somewhere around season 6, leaving Berman & Braga in charge. They are the distastrous duo responsible for Enterprise, the show that killed the franchise. With Voyager they took all of Taylor's hard work in character development, completely ignored it, and came up with this godawful idea to put Seven of Nine with Chakotay. Prior to this Jeri Taylor had spent five or six seasons building a slow-burning, unrequited but potential pairing in Janeway and Chakotay. When Seven of Nine arrived in season 4 (and when Jeri Ryan subsequently turned out to have brains as well as bazookas, and probably a better actress than they gave her credit for), she was mentored by the Doctor, who had previously been established as having a weakness for blondes and shortly thereafter fell in love with his protegée. Voyager was never particularly subtle about its pairings, but nevertheless, they were fun.

I will talk about both of these pairings later in this meme (breaking the repeated-fandom rule already...). I really don't want to talk about this pairing because it pains me to my very core. It's just that bloody awful.

Okay, here's a picture. Brace yourselves.


Picture source: Ugo.Com - The Most Absolutely Awful TV Couples (I think that says it all...)


I can't remember which episode this is from, and frankly I don't care. DNW FOREVER.

The precursor to Chakotay/Seven was that Seven wanted to practice dating (on the Doc's advice, obviously) and had created a holographic version of Chakotay in order to do so. There was nothing remotely premeditated or emotional about this decision; she merely went through the crew roster and selected a 'mate' based on their various attributes. That episode, "Human Error", ironically also contains some of my very favourite Doc/Seven moments, in the 'reality' side of the episode.

It was supposed to begin and end there, until Robert Beltran (Chakotay) moaned about not having enough story involvement and the writers, in their infinite wisdom, decided to pair him with Seven. DESPITE THE SIX AND A HALF YEARS OF SLOW-BURNING TENSION BETWEEN HIM AND JANEWAY.

There was an episode, a few after "Human Error", in which Chakotay and Seven were stranded on an alien planet and had to work together, which was the very flimsy premise upon which they were supposed to become interested in each other. But honestly? It's a big pile of horse-dren. The two characters had barely spoken to each other and barely even knew each other. It makes Seven look weak, and Chakotay predictable. To make matters worse, by the penultimate episode, "Renaissance Man", they had the Doctor's matrix destabilising and him confessing all his last wishes in case he never got to say them, resulting in him professing his love for Seven - who by this point was already dating Chakotay. It was a pairing that not only tortured viewers, but characters as well.

Of course, we never got to see what Janeway thought of all this either. I like to think she silently castrated him in his sleep. ;) Not just for the obvious betrayal (god damn it, man, she was waiting until everyone got home!) but because he chose Seven, of all the people on the ship, to pursue - her rehabilitated Borg child and substitute daughter.

doec and I did some 'missing scene' scripts for "Endgame", the season finale when Chakotay/Seven was officially 'announced' by future!Janeway, to try and fix that horrible decision and its horrible outcomes. I can't think of a pairing that produced more hatred and alienated more groups of shippers than this one. I didn't want to believe it when I heard the spoilers, and when it actually happened I still couldn't believe what I was seeing. The unfortunate end result was that my Janeway/Chakotay pairing became irreversibly marred; Seven has always been one of my favourite characters, but I could never forgive the character mangling of Chakotay. Occasionally I like to rewatch "Resolutions" - which I will post about in due course - to make myself feel better, but it doesn't last long.

Phew. I can't believe I wrote more words about my least favourite ship than I did for my favourite. So much hate, though. So much.
Tags: fandom: star trek, memes, shippiness
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 10 comments